An atheist friend of mine hates the Bible, mostly because of the Old Testament: the violent wars, people struck dead, and idea of a fearful God. My friend doesn’t understand those stories from a Christian perspective. But if he did, he’d probably hate Scripture even more.
Like the time Uzzah gives God a helping hand, and God kills him for it.

The Ark of the Covenant was the center of Israel’s worship, but after a few hundred years it was lost to the Philistines in a war. For seven months, those Philistines experienced plagues and panic, so they sent the Ark back to Israel. There, it languished in a backwater village for sixty years.
Finally, after David is crowned king, he decides to bring the Ark home to his new capital, the recently captured Jerusalem. He arranges an elaborate celebration, displays the Ark to be seen by all, and orchestrates a parade of thousands to escort the Ark to its new home.
On the way to Jerusalem, the oxen pulling the cart stumble, and Uzzah—one of the cart’s drivers—puts out his hand to steady the Ark, and:
The anger of the Lord was kindled against Uzzah, and God struck him down there because of his error, and Uzzah died there beside the Ark of God. (2 Sam. 6:7)
Uzzah tries to help God and he is annihilated. Let’s admit it: we hate stories like this.
They All Did Everything Wrong
God gave detailed instructions for building the Tabernacle. He also gave precise commands for transporting the Ark. David and his merry band broke every single rule:
- The Ark was to be covered, not left open on display.
- The Ark was to be carried on poles, not put on a cart.
- The Ark was not to be touched, but people handled it to place it on the cart.
- The entire transportation was to be managed by Levites, which Uzzah wasn’t.
It’s easy to think Uzzah was punished because God blesses good people who obey, and he smites the bad people who disobey. But here, everybody screwed up:
- From the Levites who should have known better,
- To the people who man-handled the Ark onto the oxcart,
- To the celebrants who gaped at the Ark,
- To King David who orchestrated the entire fiasco.
Why didn’t they all drop dead? Why pick on poor Uzzah? After all, he was helping God not fighting Him: Uzzah was just trying to keep the Ark from the defilement of falling in the dirt.
Do We Really Know What God Needs?
Uzzah’s problem was not primarily breaking God’s rules (though I don’t recommend it), it was his shameless confidence in himself. He thought, “I have a good heart; I believe in God; I believe in the Bible. And I know exactly what God needs.”
How do we know Uzzah’s mindset? Look at his innate instincts: he grabs hold of the Ark because he believes the dirt of the soil will defile the Ark. But it never dawns on him that the dirt of his own soul might be far more defiling. Such pride was a habit of his heart. So Uzzah gives God that helpful nudge.
He is not alone. We all think we know exactly what God needs to do. When God doesn’t do it, none of us admit our complete and utter incompetence; instead, we simply take charge:
- When Abraham and Sarah try to help God, they birth Ishmael whose descendants war with the Israelites for millennia.
- Moses tries to help God by killing an Egyptian, and he is put out to pasture for forty years.
- Paul thought he was helping God by killing Christians, and God has to tell him, “You are persecuting Me!”
I have seen disaster after disaster by well-meaning believers who “know” how to help God: from parents controlling kids, husbands and wives controlling each other, and pastors and elder boards controlling congregations.
We are absolutely convinced that we know exactly what needs to happen and that God is going to get it wrong unless we step in and help Him. We forget that “Unless the Lord builds the house, the laborers work in vain.” It is His work that is at stake, not ours.
Isaiah is praised for his complete lack of self-assurance. He receives his commission only after he laments, “Woe to me, for I am a man of unclean lips.” (Hardly an endorsement for a prophet.)
The reason we hate these stories is we are afraid that God is going to blow it.
And it’s killing us.
Sam

Biblical Holiness Means Non-Conformity
It is remarkable how prone to wander I am, or how many times a day I might think, “I’m doing x, y and z so I must be doing all right!” Thanks for always nudging me back to seeing my deep need and God’s ever-deeper grace, Sam.
Enjoyed the post – we humans still get ourselves way out over the end of our skis – want to get things done, think it through and move forward. Want to get things done right??? Start with the instruction manual! All things are designed to work a certain way.
Keep it up – we’re out here
Love that we can wrestle with scripture together.
I’ve been using a hermeneutic that has helped over the past few years… that scripture is a window through which to see and understand Jesus. And that other than a window scripture is prone to be a mirror in which we see ourselves… or some self-referential perspective.
If the OT is literal, and is a form of Holy Dictation, then the problematic passages require an attempt to reconcile the character of an angry reactive God who smites dead those whose small errors, or small part in errors, seems at odds with the character of Jesus.
Should we be constantly nervous over the possibility we’ll offend a capricious Almighty, or are we children of the King whose loving grace corrects and reorients us.
My guess is that the Trinity share a common orientation, and that the revelation of the life of Jesus and the ways of his ministry reflect the ways of the Father perfectly.
And that the authors of the OT dutifully recorded what they knew, all contributing to the story that points to Jesus.
Love your premise… That our human wisdom attempts to corner God and we conceive ourselves the irreplaceable guides to keep God on the rails.
We do our best to understand the great I Am… one day we’ll have a closer approximation.
Thanks for your thoughts… makes me think.